Meaning of Who Are You New York? - Rufus Wainwright

Rufus Wainwright's song "Who Are You New York?" offers a unique perspective on identity and success, particularly within the context of different geographic locations. The lyrics playfully juxtapose various places across the United States, suggesting that one's significance and identity are often tied to specific locations.

The song begins with the assertion, "You ain't big unless you're big in Alabama, Don't know who you are unless you made it in Wichita," highlighting the idea that one's status and recognition are measured by their success in certain areas. Wainwright continues to emphasize this notion throughout the song, referencing places like Mississippi, Topeka, and Texas, suggesting that achieving recognition in these locations validates one's significance.

However, amidst the humor and wit of the lyrics, there is a deeper commentary on the fleeting nature of fame and the arbitrary nature of societal standards. Wainwright sings, "Gotta get back to Kansas, Or at least southern North Carolina," implying a sense of longing for a simpler, more authentic existence away from the pressures of societal expectations.

The repetition of certain phrases and locations, such as "Gotta get back to Kansas," serves to reinforce the theme of searching for identity and meaning beyond external validation. Wainwright challenges the notion that success in specific places defines one's worth, suggesting that true fulfillment comes from within rather than from external accolades.

The song's bridge introduces a more contemplative tone, as Wainwright muses, "God forbid, Southern Pennsylvania, God forbid, Eastern California, God forbid, Western New York state." These lines reflect a sense of resignation and acceptance that one's identity cannot be confined to specific geographic boundaries, and that true fulfillment lies in embracing the complexity of one's identity beyond external markers of success.

In conclusion, Rufus Wainwright's "Who Are You New York?" is a whimsical yet introspective exploration of identity, success, and the arbitrary nature of societal standards. Through its clever lyrics and playful melody, the song invites listeners to question the notion of identity tied to specific locations and encourages a deeper exploration of self-discovery and authenticity.