Meaning of 1939 Returning - Pete Doherty

Pete Doherty's song "1939 Returning" delves into the intricate layers of history, memory, and personal narratives. Through its poignant lyrics, the song encapsulates the experiences of individuals caught in the tumultuous events of World War II and its aftermath.

The opening lines, "Captured Clandestine, Crawled into the light," evoke a sense of secrecy and emergence, perhaps representing the struggles of individuals caught behind enemy lines during the war. These individuals, symbolized by the protagonist, faced the harsh reality of war and the uncertainty of survival.

The reference to "the frozen Rhine" and "the Motherland" hints at the German perspective of the war, portraying a soldier's sacrifice for their country. The juxtaposition of sacrifice and inevitability, expressed through phrases like "A toe-ing's as good as a shoeing, When it’s not to be your night," underscores the futility and randomness of fate in wartime.

As the narrative shifts, the song paints a picture of post-war Britain, particularly focusing on the plight of London's children amidst the rubble and chaos of bombings. The imagery of "London urchins grey with dust" and their evacuation to the countryside reflects the disruption and displacement experienced by countless families during the conflict.

The verses also touch upon the experiences of the elderly, like "Nana doll," who recall the upheavals of war and its lasting impact on their lives. The mention of "sheltered accommodation" and the prevalence of "pills" as a remedy for the blues speaks to the loneliness and challenges faced by those who lived through such traumatic times.

In the final verses, the song transitions to a more contemporary setting, with references to modern technology like the "tv guide" and the year "2009." Despite the passage of time, the lingering pain and longing for lost loved ones persist, as seen in the line, "Oh how it's hurting me, I’ve only seen her twice, Since she went west for the second time, Since 1939."

Overall, "1939 Returning" serves as a powerful reflection on the enduring impact of war on individuals and society as a whole. Through its evocative lyrics and haunting melody, the song invites listeners to contemplate the interconnectedness of past and present, memory and reality, in shaping our collective understanding of history.